Skip to content
InstructAsylum Research

Independent Country of Origin Information & Risk of Return expert evidence.

Objective geopolitical expert evidence for immigration and asylum proceedings, prepared with an overriding duty to the decision-maker.

Coloured pins marking places on a map
Country evidence, placed and sourced
Independent
An overriding duty to the decision-maker, not the instructing party.
Fully sourced
Every proposition carries a citation the tribunal can follow.
Objective only
Country conditions, never the claimant's credibility.
Legal aid welcome
Scoped costings and legal aid rates on request.
Library reading room lined with bookshelves
The wider record, read in full

Official country guidance

How expert evidence contextualises government COI notes.

Official country guidance and policy notes are evidence, not a determination. Where a state relies on its own country materials, the expert identifies the underlying sources, weighs them against the wider evidence base (UNHCR, EUAA/ecoi.net, peer-reviewed scholarship, and reliable in-country reporting), and sets out where the objective picture diverges.
  1. 01

    Map the official source base

    Identify every citation relied upon: its date, authorship, and methodology.

  2. 02

    Triangulate against the wider record

    Place those propositions beside NGO, academic, and conflict-monitor evidence that the note omits or underweights.

  3. 03

    State divergence with citation

    Where conclusions diverge, explain why, with an audit trail the decision-maker can follow.

Evidential domains

Subjective fear is for the decision-maker. Objective risk is the expert’s domain.

Subjective fear

For the decision-maker

What the claimant says happened to them, and why they fear return. Credibility findings belong exclusively to the decision-maker.

Objective risk

For the expert

What the evidence establishes about conditions facing a person of the relevant profile: state and non-state actors, protection in practice, and whether relocation is both safe and reasonable. A person cannot be expected to conceal a protected characteristic to avoid harm.

Expert evidence should be, and should be seen to be, the independent product of the expert, uninfluenced as to form or content by the exigencies of litigation, with an overriding duty to help the decision-maker on matters within the expert’s expertise.

Expert duty to the court or tribunal

Ready to instruct?

Instructions from legal practitioners, legal aid providers, NGOs, and tribunals worldwide. Use generic references only (e.g. Claimant AA (Iraq)).